Al Gore makes a point about global warming to a bunch of white people in Hay-on-Wye.
Ah, Al. Why didn't you say these things years ago? (The jokes, I mean. That environment stuff, I read all about in Earth in the Balance, which is the only place it got any print.)
Which was exactly what one young man in the audience asked after the event, and Al, unlike his old prevaricating self, acknowledged his own inability to articulate the problems besetting the environment. He now wishes to make us all articulate enough to make the message our own, to go out into the world and preach the gospel of global warming.
Indeed, the whole thing reminded me of a sermon. Not one I ever heard in the Church of the Male Patriarchy I grew up attending, but the southern cadence of Al Gore's delivery did sound more Baptist than academic. If we had been anywhere but a few miles from the border of England and Wales, the audience would surely have punctuated the address with a few well-placed amens.
The Hay Festival would have been well suited to host a revival meeting. The overwhelming impression was of whiteness: large white tents, connected by boardwalks that lifted festival goers above the muck of the field where the event took place. Nor did I see a non-white face, despite the fact the Hay Festival is billed as the "Woodstock of the mind." Again, we were in the Welsh countryside, where there are more black sheep than non-Caucasians.
One point about the festival, before I move on to Al: Unless you have tickets to an event, which cost between £5 and £35, don't bother making the three and a half hour drive from London. While there are plenty of events—mostly talks by authors—there's not much else to do at the Festival itself. I don't know about here, but in the U.S. talks by authors are a dime a dozen. Actually not even that much. Every mid-sized American city has a steady stream of writers who'll talk for free. But I highly recommend a visit to Hay-on-Wye, preferably when there aren't thousands of visitors clogging its charming streets. With 41 new and used bookstores in the tiny town, it's a bibliophile's mecca.
But I hadn't come for the books; I came to hear what the blogosphere is buzzing about: Al Gore and his "The Glaciers are Melting; the Earth is Hurtling Toward Hell in a Handbasket; Quick, Repent and Buy Carbon Offsets!" sermon. Er, speech.
Al Gore has a great comedy routine, which surprises a lot of people who thought the press had accurately nailed him as being stiff and pedantic. I never thought that, but then I find pedants rather charming. The opening lines of his speech were actually funnier than his SNL performance. He told the story about how he and Tipper were seen at a Shoney's in Tennessee. The next day the rumour had started that they'd opened a chain of restaurants. The audience laughed at this, but would probably have found it funnier if they'd known just how much the press had mangled every word Gore uttered while he was a politician.
He did again joke that he's a recovering politician, on Step 9 of his recovery program. I wish him luck, though the American woman in front of me, who was one of the ones chosen to ask a question, used her time to beg him to run again. We were all a bit uncomfortable by this display of raw emotion in a sea of British reticence. A British crowd is very different from a fervent American audience. When Gore finished his talk, a few people stood up, while the others remained seated, clapping as unstrenuously as possible.
I won't restate everything he said about the crisis facing the planet; nothing surprised me, but one thing really did crystallize the problem we face.
He said that in 1998 a team of scientists reviewed 928 peer-reviewed studies on climate; none disagreed with the consensus that global warming exists and is man-made.
They then reviewed 14 years of major news articles on the subject, amounting to 626 articles, and 53% disagreed with the concensus.
Let me say this again, brothers and sisters: 53%.
(Ironically, on the way over we listened to a radio program where someone claimed individual attempts to save energy—double glazing, efficient appliances, etc., would not recoup their costs in energy savings over the lifetime of the product. According to the energy expert I consulted, who happened to be driving my car, the guy was reciting 25-year old research, and is flat wrong.)
The argument culture of the media is responsible for a lot of wrongheaded thinking, the kind you hear your neighbors, in-laws, and anonymous airport passengers spout off. Thanks to the press and their urge to present both sides, even when one side manufactures their facts out of thin air (which is, by the way, "good for you!!!") most Americans are totally ignorant of the truth, which is simply that our Earth has never been in more danger.
It's as if a comet is hurtling straight at us, and half the world refuses to believe the evidence despite a huge shadow growing bigger with every hurricane season.
Don't run for president, Al. Preach to us instead. Scare the pants off us with your tales of fire and brimstone, charm us with your self-deprecating humor, wow us with your PowerPoint slides. That groundswell you hear may just be another rumbling from Gaia Earth, or it may be evidence of a real sea change—in thinking, not melting glaciers. I'm a cynic, especially when it comes to religion and politics, but maybe you're the right guy to lead us out of this darkness and into the solar-powered light.
I hear there's nothing like a recovering sinner for preaching the gospel.